Your Incredible Shrinking Paycheck

Excellent article on the state of affairs in terms of both the United States and global economies. In my view, what this all basically means for the average American citizen is that the best of times are behind us, and the future looks bleak. TGO

Refer to story below. Source: TIME

By RANA FOROOHAR Rana Foroohar Tue Mar 1, 9:00 am ET

Before I started writing this column on why paychecks are likely to keep shrinking even if unemployment starts to inch down, I consulted Google to see if the term Marxism was trending upward. It was and has been ever since the end of December, the conclusion of a year in which workers’ share of the U.S. economic pie shrank to the smallest piece ever: 54.4% of GDP, down from about 60% in the 1970s.

No wonder Marx is back in fashion. It’s been more than 100 years since the German philosopher predicted that capitalism’s voraciousness would be its undoing – as bosses invest more in new technologies to make things more cheaply and efficiently and less in workers themselves, who, deprived of fair wages, would eventually rise up and revolt. That hasn’t happened, of course, though depressed wages certainly contributed to the revolution in Egypt, not to mention lots of other instances of public unrest over the past few years. But the fact that wages in the U.S. and most other rich countries have been falling since the 1970s and went off a cliff after the recent financial crisis is going to become a more pressing economic and political concern. Just think how hard it will be for Obama to sell himself in 2012 if salaries are still falling. (See 25 people to blame for the financial crisis.)

And fall they have, to an extent not seen since the 1930s. Labor Department figures show that from 2007 to 2009, more than half the full-time workers who lost jobs and then found new work took pay cuts. A depressing 36% had to take positions paying 20% less than the ones they lost.

The drop in wages occurs in part because unemployment rose so sharply and widely after the crisis and has remained higher for longer than in past recessions. Both factors have led to a disconnect between labor supply and demand that makes it tough for workers to negotiate better deals. Forget about driving a hard bargain with a new boss. Most of us feel lucky just to have bosses, and we work as hard as we can to keep them happy – as the productivity figures emphatically show.

Yet even if unemployment starts to ease, it’s unclear whether labor’s portion of the pie will stop shrinking. The global headwinds may be too strong. Just as Marx predicted, technology-driven productivity is increasing not just in manufacturing but also in services. Even the financial wizards that caused the crisis aren’t immune. While trading volumes and the size of global markets have increased dramatically in the past 20 years, Wall Street still employs roughly the same number of people. If you’ve ever watched a trader working a three-screen Bloomberg terminal flashing hundreds of prices in dozens of countries, you’ll understand why. (See TIME’s Wall Street covers.)

The other megatrend of our age, the rise of emerging markets, will also continue to put pressure on U.S. wages. According to Goldman Sachs, more than 70 million people in developing countries become middle-class consumers each year. That’s great for us in some ways, because it means they’ll have money to buy goods made by companies in the rich world. But it also means they’ll have the skills necessary to do our jobs. A lot of Wall Street data crunching, for example, is now done in India, and the number of high-end strategy jobs in fields like consulting is increasing there too.

The latter trend is gaining on the former. A recent study by Capital Economics found that from 2002 to 2008, employment abroad by U.S. multinationals rose 22.6%, while employment at home increased by a mere 4.9%. What’s good for U.S. companies and what’s good for U.S. labor and wages are no longer always the same thing. The discrepancy may become an increasingly contentious political issue.

The best way to mitigate the fallout – which may include the rise of ugly populist politics – is to focus on social mobility. While rich-country wages will be increasingly compressed across the board, those at the top of the socioeconomic scale will feel the pressure much less. The goal, then, should be to push more people upward. Portable pensions and health care reform would help by allowing laid-off workers with skills to move more easily to places where they can command good jobs. Creative retraining programs would help as well. Denmark provides a good example: when companies there shed workers because of outsourcing, the government continues to pay those workers for two years, but on a declining scale and only with the promise that they attend retraining programs for jobs in higher-growth industries.

None of these are easy or quick solutions to shrinking wages. But they are a lot better than the Marxist alternative.

See people protesting the bank bailouts.

See which businesses are bucking the recession.

View this article on

Most Popular on

3 responses

  1. Good blog entry regarding Marxist philosophy. It’s nice to see someone who can discuss Marx in a rational manner without the screams of “COMME” ringing in the ears.

    While Marx made some good points, we must remember that he is NOT nor ever was remotely the same thing as communist Russia or China. Moreover, he wrote 100 years ago and things have changed in the world… but he brought up some downsides to the capitalist ideology. For a more modern take, I would suggest reading Herbert Schiller.

    The one thing I think about when faced with the relentlessness of capitalist greed is this: Who will be left to buy the excess surplus of goods, when the population does not make enough money to do so? Eventually the system will fall, when the income disparity becomes so unequal and the majority cannot purchase anything.

    We saw some of this happen during the Depression. People simply quit buying.


  2. I enjoy reading your Blog, very good.


    1. Thanks!


Comments please...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 137 other followers

%d bloggers like this: